Hi,

I’m feeling a bit disappointed today because my startup wasn’t chosen for a $5k grant from one of the startup funds at my university. Any advice?

After interviewing last week and answering a series of questions related to my startup, I was confident that we’d get chosen. My co-founder and I previously finished another incubator program at my university where we were granted $5k in seed funding.

In the interview, I spoke about how we’re currently talking to potential customers in our niche, getting them interested and building our mailing list (almost 200 emails). I spoke about how we’re launching our app first to build a customer base before releasing our device. We’re both technical so I’m building the app which will be finished in December and he’s focusing on the device engineering and we collaborate on both. I also mentioned some of our other wins such as being accepted into another incubator program where we’ll get additional funding ($7.5k) in the summer and securing a meeting with a VC for a 25k investment which is part of a larger $500k investment (I didn’t mention the $500k though, just $25k).

I felt like the interviewers (who are also students at my university) weren’t really feeling the business because I got the question “what makes your product different from products X and Y that already exists on the market”. This questions was interesting because products X and Y are completely different products than what we’re building. X and Y are treatment devices while ours is closer to an analysis and diagnostic device. I mentioned that we are working to incorporate aspects of products X and Y into ours to give users a reason to use the tool every day as opposed to when issues pop up for them and they need to get help.

I don’t know if oversharing during a startup grant interview is a thing but I’m feeling like maybe I said something that turned them off, they don’t think we need the funding since we have other opportunities (even though we do need it) or they just didn’t believe in our idea.

It sucks that we didn’t get chosen for the funding but the grind continues. Better luck next time we apply :)

  • DonovanBanks@alien.topB
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    1
    ·
    10 months ago

    If strangers can’t see the difference between yours and your competitors, then your customers won’t either.

    You being involved in it, means you will have bias that makes you THINK it is different. But if it solves the same problem, but in a different way, then it’s no different.

    Like a bus and a train are very different. But to someone who wants to get across town it doesn’t matter that much.

    Maybe ask them for some feedback to see where you can improve.

  • kulukster@alien.topB
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    1
    ·
    10 months ago

    They might have wanted to spread the investment around and chose a project that had not received funding before.

  • hinterland_skis@alien.topB
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    1
    ·
    10 months ago

    Find yourself a marketing professional and have them help you with your messaging. Most of the time technical people are terrible at pitches. You’re likely too smart. Sales people are the way they are for a reason.

  • badheartbull@alien.topB
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    1
    ·
    10 months ago

    Volume…. What do I mean? We send out 1-3 proposals for contracts/grants every day. Sometimes we have 150 pending at any given time. Spent six months perfecting the systems and 10 years becoming a pro at capture management. Our larger enterprise competitors handle about 12 funding opportunities per day.

    Oh, and those days or weeks where you think funding is temporarily closed off due to “just getting back into the office” - yeah that’s a moment to be bidding/fundraising. Think contrary to your market.

  • MrKeys_X@alien.topB
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    1
    ·
    10 months ago

    Use it as fuel to prove them wrong. And you can keep them posted about your progress.

    Back in the day, when a potential investor didn’t invest in my company, i put them on a ‘newsletter’. And after years and years of building relationships, it has been one of my best moves till date, to keep them simply in the loop. Good luck.