We went through a handful of software as well for clocking in/out. You still have the same problem. The employees have to still push a button to clock in, lunch, out. Which has not worked. However we are now trying a different approach. We have a new clock in software where employees can receive tokens for proper clocking in. Once they earned enough they can trade them in for gift cards to a number of places or items that the software provides. We are trying the reward system to give the employees a incentive to clock in/out properly so hopefully it sticks. Also we will be having weekly meetings to remind employees of the incentive and to market it to them as a big positive as part of the implementation process of the new software. cross fingers!