Ok, so here is my take on this situation, let’s assume that your product is a pillow (not sure what it is but for this conversation it’s irrelevant for the most part), I go into a store and see your high grade high quality made in America pillow for $29.99 and next to it I see an identical pillow that is lower quality and lower grade for $21.99 I will take the the lower grade and then while at home bitch that nothing is made here in the states and I’ll think I’m one person I won’t make a difference if I buy the American made pillow.

Exceptions to this are part of the conspicuous waste and conspicuous precision. So high end products that are marketed to few and longed after by masses can get away with this, so Rolex and a $50,000 watch uses high grade parts for the final product. So don’t operate in the middle, either have a high end product or an entry level product. Is my suggestion.